lying about address for school

What else can happen? I would not cheat, did not cheat. Anon. anon, Decent schools should be available to every family. Students who lie can become skilled at the behavior; the lying then might become habitual to the point that they lie with little concern for the consequences, which can be considerable. Don't go hiding behind anonymous tip lines and point fingers - own up to what you're doing. Instead of telling eachother what to do, how about telling our politicians how to better serve ALL the children in this state? The poster originally wrote in feeling an ethical dilemma and I think was trying to consider all the sides of the issue. It has developed high academic standards for all students and a new system of accountability, but academic progress has been slow. Whether their parents worked ''hard'' or not. Besides, I asked my middle school child's teacher about this, and she said that even if they do know, they don't kick a child out unless they have MAJOR behavior/grade issues, or are in some sort of special needs program that requires a lot of extra funding. I cant help but draw the parallel - you drew it yourself when you used the word ''legal''to refer to the children who live in the district. Do unto others as you would have done unto you. I think what the family is doing is wrong, but if you do anything about it, you could end up hating yourself. You're imposing your own sense of right and wrong on the world. It's a much bigger picture and I think blowing the whisle on one family is not going to accomlish anything except heartache for that family and you living with what you have done (good or bad). West Orange . Do I have to let him in? Good luck and now that I've probably offended 1/2 the readers, I'll go now. annonymous, I am one of the persons who originally responded to this and I see whoever wrote in ''troubled'' about the postings may have misunderstood mine or some other of the responses. First, that blowing the whistle will hurt the kid. Yes, that was the case with my kids - now in high school and burning through AP classes. He thrived in the new school. I think lying to get your kid a better education sends a bad message to your children. oringal poster, I was recently surprised to learn of students who attend high school in one town yet live in another (in this case, kids who live in Richmond yet attend either Albany or Berkeley high), providing those high schools with false or former addresses. I think the worst part would be that your child would have to lie to teachers/ friends about where he lives or if administration heard otherwise he could be ''kicked out'' midyear or at any juncture in his schooling and have to start somewhere else. But if it's already a done deal and I find out about it, should I keep my mouth shut, or ''tattle'' to the powers that be in order to satisfy my own idea of right and wrong? good luck. Board of Education Credentials & Criminal Records in Nevada How to Address Chronic Lying: Stage a Lying Intervention. A Teacher, I know everyone means well by his or her advice but I am very troubled by some of the posts trying to impose what they believe is the proper ethical duty in school selection. We're well aware of the ethical issues but when our child is suffering, it's hard to be a purist. If the district accepted the transfer, the case is closed. in your name at the address. let your conscience decide. Using a relative's or friend's address to enroll a child who does not live at that address. Second, that the family is okay doing this because the school district where they live is lousy. Very often schools that have high minority populations show test scores that reflect just that - poor people do less well on standardized tests. anon. I would appreciate any insight on this before we move forward. If you are talking about a place like Piedmont, I know someone who lives on the border and tried to legally get their child into the district through the petition process, and was turned down flat EVEN THOUGH the school in question was under-enrolled with locals, who mostly opted to send their kids to pricey private schools instead. If you don't like your local school district, then MOVE! Even though you say you wouldn't be a cheater, I can only hope that if your child's welfare were at stake, you'd do the same. We go to our neighborhood school in El Cerrito (Harding) and have found that the teachers have an average of 15-20 years of experience, there is an active parent population, and we love the network of close playmates, and the feeling of really being part of the neighborhood. Anonymous, I'm sure this will be a controversial topic, but I think you should mind your own business, and not be so quick to judge people for ''lying'' to give their kids a chance for a decent education. Before you report anyone for ''cheating'' to get into a school, I'd urge you to double-check your motives and accept that most of these kids are already known to the school --- you may not get any reaction at all to your moral dilemma, or not the reaction you expect. It is not the kids fault, but they pay the biggest price. The kid is the one who will suffer, and they are innocent in all of this. Please don't do it. The child has established herself in the school, made friends, etc. The concequences are not so big for you, but they are for the kids. Other occupational licenses 7.1. 2022 Homecoming Season. Has your child been denied a spot in his/her home school because of the out of district child? Some school districts, like West Orange's, are using residency investigators to recoup thousands of dollars in tuition from families where students pretend to live in the township. You have no idea how desperate it feels just making it (financialy) and to be faced with the prospect of sending your child or children to a school that is a 1 out of ten. Please take a moment to check out this intelligent explanation of California schools: First to Worst: http://www.pbs.org/merrow/tv/ftw/ Here is a quick excerpt.. ''First to Worst explores the roots of California's current education crisis, tracing it to the anti-tax movement of the 1970's and 80's and to civil rights lawsuits that aimed to equalize school spending but resulted instead in disastrous funding limits on schools. Her son finished out high school and is in college now. Once again, for those of you that provided valuable input, I do thank you. Good luck. anonymous, I'm responding in part to all the responses you received. How horrible to be pulled out of school! Albany Parent. It's such a bad model for your friend's child, too. I volunteered at a public school in a working class neighborhood and was so disheartend by how many truly bright kids were slipping through the cracks because their parents did not know how to work the system. Kudos to you! Community colleges push to get more minority students onboard - USA TODAY Either way, the assumption that school children would automatically shun anyone who is not a close neighbor from their area is scary to me. Lying isn't typically an action against you as a parent. BUT, I think it's a great idea. Teens With ADHD and Lying - Understood You have privelege because your kid goes to a ''desireable'' school - leave the people who are not as priveleged alone. First, I'm sorry that so many people angrily responded to your post with ''it's none of your business''. Lying is ok, Okay - the out-of-district stuff is not right. If you tell, you might feel very righteous and a ''deserving'' child might get the spot. I want them to have enough textbooks to go around, to have clean classrooms and toilets that flush. It stinksbut at this point I don't know the correct moral thing to do. We don't have a lot left over at the end of the month because our rent is high, and our house is kind of shabby. School Enrollment Fraud Can Be Costly - FindLaw Administrators sometimes did room checks at houses to make sure kids really lived at the in-district addresses. anon. It can be done without giving your own name, and all the district needs is the name of the other family and they will check into it. Thanks. Could we go buy a home in Richomond or parts of Oakland or Emeryville? The issue should not be will I get caught? Here's the long answer: Schools are required by state law to verify ''residency,'' not ownership. m, My thoughts are in the form of a few questions and a response. I myself attended AHS when living in El Cerrito, as an out of district student, but my parents owned property in Alany and therefore paid the taxes you are referring to. How are those consequences communicated? Period. anon, if your mother lives in Albany they have actual officers check homes for residency claims and the child must have a bedroom/ markable space in the house. I've known more than a few people who have done this over the years. This story . 3. state or federal tax returns AND W2 or 1099 attached; payroll/check stub with name and address; or correspondence from a gov't agency w/your address on it. Father who lied about address during Pri 1 registration gets fine Many of the families walk to school too. At the university I go to they have a rule that you must either live on campus, be 21, or live with your parents. My 12 year old son has been lying to the school nurse and school and now I am going to court because off my . For now, all is fair in love, and fulfilling the needs of our children. Also consider that other children who live in the district (especially those who move into the area the summer prior to the school year) may have to go to another school if families such as yours dishonestly attend their school district. From what I hear, administrators turn a blind eye most of the time because the families that go to the lengths to sneak their kids into another school system generally are very involved at the school, give generously and have kids who are highly motivated. I find this is particularly true when people from the mainstream culture make assumptions about the lives of people who may be of a different race or economic background. It is one of the tactics deployed by students keen on benefitting from school financial aid programs by all means, even if it requires cutting corners. You risk being caught. She applied as an out of district student when her daughter was in elementary school, and though they haven't taken many, if any out of district students in recent years, once your in, your in. Some districts are paid by student enrollment, some aren't. Apparently just owning a property and paying the taxes there is not acceptable---you are supposed to live in it. Dr. Ken Shore's Classroom Problem Solver Lying in Class Most children lie sometimes. She lives in the area, so she could attend the school even if her parents inputted the real address, but lying to a school district seems illegal. This is to the original poster. This is an ugly issue for schools, one that is primarily about money. but, Is it right? Please no nasty responses! Parent/guardian passport; Driver's AND vehicle or boat license; Calif ID; or military ID, 2. rental/lease agreement with written verification from manager, with manager/owner contact info; property tax bill; or homeowner's/renter's insurance policy. The point should be whether the laws are just and fair, not if somebody breaks them. I don't think this is a good way for children to spend their childhoods. Cathy, Absolutely not! Former ODA mom of a wildly successful teen who survived a drug addicted parent thanks to BHS. Would you do it if you were in their situation? First off, I would not ''blow the whistle'' on this family due to all the reasons given by other parents. sign me Playing Fair. Don't cheapen yourself with petty vindications in the name of morality. We were not at home at the time, so they left a card. It comes down to what I am willing to sacrifice in order to place him in a better school. However, because I allowed a friend to use my address I wanted to weigh in on the other side of the argument. As a believer in karma, that situation will evolve the way it is supposed to but to insinuate yourself into a situation that has NOTHING TO DO WITH YOU, you are only setting yourself up for your own fall. In life, parents make hard choices when their kids are in need. It's not possible for every one to be able to afford housing in these desirable districts. School Residency Fraud Can Be Charged As a Felony I'm assuming you're talking either of Albany HS, MS or Berkeley High. They showed a delapitaded school in San Pablo in stark contrast with another school in Orinda or one of the places nearby. It's totally unfair. So, though I can sympathize with your concern, and no, it isn't ''fair'' that this child displaces someone whom the rules favor, it also isn't fair that this child doesn't have an alternative that is equally desirable. Seems to me the kid from the district ought to get preference here. anonymous, Don't do it. The district is well aware that there are many out of district students in the school system, and have chosen not to do much about it. I agree with the posters who have listed various factors to consider in determining the right educational district for your child. My friend lives too far for the nanny's daughter to attend her district. America Tonight If all public schools were made to be ''desirable'' parents would not feel the desperate need to lie in order to get their children into a good school. You can refuse to do this, there could possibly be consequences if the school district found out but also you may have to PROVE the address by a utility bill, landlord, mortgage, etc. I do not know the reasons the family made the choice to place their child in this school. Lying about your address for school isn't considered illegal. I have a friend who lied about residency to get her kids into the school district she wanted (using a friend's address as her own). My husband and I work hard to afford where we live. Lying about your address for schools | Selfish school catchment zone fraud for school waiting lists or enrolment in Australia.This is a slide show with no so. But this time, I really feel compelled to respond. Trying to walk the walk. As the parent of a special needs kid, I know there are less funds (and staff availability) because there are out of district kids using special needs resources. I know one mom, the only reason she works is so they can live in a better school area, now is that fair to her? My mother's neighborhood school is ranked very high; however, I would have to lie to enroll my son. An active PTA can supplement what California's cash-strapped schools are no longer providing by covering new playground equipment, paying for a music teacher, field trips, etc. HOpe this is helpful. Instead, we were assigned to a school that is just above the no-child-left-behind cut off. Would you want someone to upset your child's routine and sense of security because you made a decision that you felt you needed to for your family? And why should they have to have a MILLION DOLLAR HOUSE to get their kid a good school, anyway? That is hardly just and ''right'' by that child, just so things can be ''right'' in your eyes, in other ways. But I've also taught in several schools of various rankings that I think would be great places for my kid. Do you have something against this child or the parents? "After high school, you really have two choices: You can go to college or go to work." In an ideal world, the decision should be easy. I'm in the minority here, but I think they should be ratted out to the district. I don't regret my decision in the least. -Got a good school on lottery, but may have done anything to get out of a bad school. Can parents or children face criminal consequences for using a fake Don't further the wrongs of a messed of system by calling out another family who is just trying to do the best for their kid. In Oakland there is only one decent junior high school -- Montera -- and for folks with incomes that don't put them in the montclair area, the others don't even come close. Similarly, are scores high because testing is the main focus of the school, at the cost of other programs like art, music, science, etc? The various ruses used (investment property, non-existent or illegal in-law units, business address, etc.) It is also known as school enrollment fraud or residency fraud. I just want to say how sorry I am to see how many people have chosen to attack you simply for asking the question you did. Should we use my mom's address for school? The finer points or morals are a cold comfort when it comes to a decent education for your children. Is this one child hurting your child's education? I don't think it is a fair system to give a difficult and intimidating test to young children who are just learning English, but that's what the state of California does. You obviously have no idea under what conditions people lie to get their children into the best school possible. Thanks! This little-discussed corner of the K-12 landscape contains so many of the issues that shape education in Pennsylvania today. And even more, do you want to help a parent who is unethical take advantage of you and your child as well as the other children in your district? Our kids come first. Or maybe you're talking about grade school, not Berkeley High, so maybe it's not their top choice school but still it's one in the district. Let them alone. Wouldn't that really suck???) I echo the majority of the prior responses on this topic which raised some really good points. It's not really that you should mind your own business, but perhaps you should keep the child's best interest in mind. This is a tricky and tough situation. Your friend should understand if you say ''I don't feel comfortable lying about this.'' Blowing the whistle on one family is not going to solve the problem. But non-socioeconomically disadvantaged students may be doing just fine, and benefitting from a wider social experience. Can you lie about your address to a school? : r/legaladvice - Reddit They think, ''Well, because you are my friend (spouse, neighbor, relative, etc.) There are many (political, funding, getting caught) reasons not to do this, but the most important is that it's so damaging to be involved in a lie. Whistle-blowing punishes the child more than the parents. I have visions of the principal knocking on our door asking to see the child's room. 18 U.S. Code 1038 - False information and hoaxes I do not think you should blow the whistle on this child's family. You need to be 'resident' in the district. The Real Cost of Address Fraud for K12 Schools - LINQ I have even heard of some neighborhood kids being turned away from their local schools because there was not space and that's just not fair. I know someone who lies to get in another school's area, and their child cannot have play dates at their house, can never get picked up or dropped off for any other activities, has to lie when they 'practice' writing their addresses, etc. While it's a bit sneaky, I would bet there are tons of folks who do the same thing so you gotta do what you gotta do. Sometimes extreme conditions call for extreme measures. I think the appropriate and ''morally right'' way to tackle an issue like this is to learn more about what has led to our schools' current state and get involved in trying to help all children get a decent education. Now, to me this is morally wrong. Unless you are intimately familiar with the life of this person, it may be unfair to second-guess his or her rationale for the action. And the poster mentioned not wanting the child to learn that lies get you what you want and depending on the school district the child would have to not tell people that he really lives somewhere else. NONE of them were the 3 kids who don't even live here! Is lying about where you live illegal? If I were you, regardless of what you decide, I would share with your friend that her request made you feel uncomfortable. Mind your own business. But it's not in the cards for us right now.
Console Log An Array Javascript, Articles L