eagle scout project rules

To be an Eagle Scout meant you were in a small group of the best of the best. That by becoming an Eagle Scout you really do stand above the rest. What i reliazed was that he needed guidance. I understand that we are in competition with video games, but making the program easy for everyone is utter nonsense. Live and learn, right? As I am looking over his service project report I am finding the workbook VERY user friendly. WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE EAGLE PROJECT? (To learn more about the Eagle Scout service project, see the Guide to Advancement, topics 9.0.2.0 through 9.0.2.15.) Why these guidelines exist As I see it the book provides clarity that protects the scout from the over-reach of leaders who try to make the project into more than the BSA is asking for. What type of info are you looking for? It works by asking a few simple questions about your key interests, then . How To Plan An Eagle Scout Project: An Easy 5-Step Guide - ScoutSmarts Getting approvals -- Ideas plus a checklist to ensure you are ready for the approval phase. Adobe Acrobat is not meant to be a wordprocessing package. No there should be accountability planning etc. As an organization, we should really look at developing a high standard a leadership, planning, and service- with a focus on producing quality and not quantity Eagle Scouts. Best Wishes to all of the Life Scouts and please please please Do your due diligence and complete your project plan and use it as part of the effective communications tool it is for your project team when you begin executing In the end the Plan is only as good as you make it and will only help you if you use it. Eagle Scout Requirement 5: Nothing was right, materials, design. Over the years over zealous volunteer leaders have imposed on scouts all kinds of extra requirements and unnecessary details to make the project meet their own descriptions of what they believe the project should entail. In this video, made for Eagle Scout candidates, Dr. John Hovanesian, Eagle adviser to Troop 35, Laguna Beach, explains how to come up with ideas for a good E. I hate to use the words dumby downed but it is apparent the next generation of scout will earn the rank easier. @J on Given the numerous typos, fractured metaphors and lack of any coherent argument, your comments about the new workbook are lost. Theres an expressionI believe it has something to do with a horse and a barn door that applies. As stated, the project proposal takes several signatures including the Scoutmaster and Committee Chair. This means if a bad project is sent up, the unit has failed! I am fighting a council rep right now that wants the Proposal like a contract proposal from a fortune 500 company. And remember that No. What constitutes enough planning? A candidate has to earn 21 merit badges varying in subject from first aid to business, assume leadership roles and execute a large community service . New Philmont overnight accommodation option makes the property more available than ever, Scout builds home for hawk, plus other good news from this week, Postcards Home program will give youth the opportunity to share their Jamboree experience, Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Service Project Planning Guidelines (PDF). Eagle Projects. 512-927, in meeting this requirement. Until next time, I'm wishing you all the best on your journey to Eagle and beyond! How do you enforce safety guidelines at service projects? First, the fact that the final adult approval is at the concept/idea point where there are not enough details to ensure safety and decent planning. As I see it the book provides clarity that protects the scout from the over-reach of leaders who try to make the project into more than the BSA is asking for. The Final Report -- Guidelines to help you. The world is very competitive, jobs are not handed to just any person, an employer looks for qualifications and reliability, like the eagle rank he will have to work to honing his skills for whatever position or occupation he wants to go into. CAN OUR DISTRICT MODIFY THE PROJECT REQUIREMENT? I agree with the comments whereby the document needs to be more user friendly. Have you ever thought about what it means to give leadership to others? I am Scoutmaster and have been involved with scouting for 22 years; our troop is the oldest in the district with 86 years. Truly, I continue mourning the loss of my father, BUT he died around the time of these changes, and Im so glad he didnt have to witness it. Unwelcome surprises will likely be the most difficult aspect of your project. The above comment is right on! ____ 2. The Eagle project must truly show leadership ability, and that quality is bought out in a young man ( 15 +) who can truly plan a project on his own and implicate it with the help of others. Eagle Scout - U.S. Scouting Service Project Advancement & Awards, Advancement & Awards FAQs, Awards and Square Knots, Eagle Palms, Eagle Scout, Leaders, Magazine, Merit Badges, Scouts BSA. It wasnt that it the project was not a good project but i thought his plan was a little lite in the initial details. I have two issues with the new plan/process. The Scout discusses the project idea with a District Advancement committee member, either by telephone or email. In fact the new workbook is a tool they can carry with them and modify for planning many activities in life. This is how it went for us. This means you should have all of your supplies, materials, and tools available and ready to be transported to your work site. Other than my son being in BSA I dont have much involvement in scouting. No racist . I also agree that the new workbook helps the scout and the leadership visualize the complete process. He requested $1000 and we dropped it to $500 and approved the amount. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from the site author is strictly prohibited. There is a prestige with such a title and to make it easily attainable then it wont be anything special. If an Eagle Coach allows a bad project ot be sent up, then he has failed. The only difference between giving leadership then and giving leadership for your Eagle Scout project is the context in which youre giving that leadership. Youll need to take charge of your project with confidence, adapt when necessary, and create the best results possible, all while also not pushing your volunteers too hard! 512-927, 2011 printing), the best source is the Guide to Advancement 2011 (No. First, Id recommend speaking with your beneficiary and assessing what else needs to be done. However, theres no shame in needing to change your expectations! The project idea must be approved by Eagle Service Project Fundraising Guidelines - BSA The first is the age guidelines for the use of hand tools and power tools, working heights and elevations, and excavations. That has not always been the case but in the end I really hope that no Scout I ever advise gets before an Eagle BOR without a complete project plan and gets turned down at their BOR because of that. If youre serving food the day of your project. Its actually best to choose and connect with your sub-leads well before the project workday ideally, at least 1-2 weeks out. To give the Scout an opportunity to "plan, develop, and give leadership to others," as noted in the requirement. While it may seem tempting to help out wherever possible (I got that urge too, trust me! The new requirements to him, and us, were clear and concise. Since its inception Ive seen better growth and results as the young men work on their project. 4. I've got complete details below. The Eagle coach is a great suggestion. These are dedicated Scouters who care about the program and the young man setting there. Let me see some ID! It is nothing more than a veiled attempt to devalue and minimize the achievements of others and that is in no way a Scouting value. Not sure what the issue was either earlier PDFs, but the one in 2019 and later works very well. For more leadership advice, check out my article on the 5 Deadly Leadership Mistakes to Avoid. Not every young man can easily take on such a challenge without supports. The project has always been descibed simply as: a service project that benefits the community, with the stipulation that the project requires the scout to demonstrate leadership in planning and carrying out the project. After a long workday, you can finally breathe a sigh of relief now that youve completed the hardest portion of your Eagle Scout Project!! Bryan Wendell, an Eagle Scout, is the founder of Bryan on Scouting (now Aaron on Scouting). Eagle Planning Guide -- Doing the Project - EagleScout.Org We are compensated for referring traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on this site. Over the years over zealous volunteer leaders have imposed on scouts all kinds of extra requirements and unnecessary details to make the project meet their own descriptions of what they believe the project should entail. Eagle Project Planning Guide -- an excellent work PDF Eagle Scout Letter of Reference - Boy Scouts of America This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. For example, we had a Scout build a 10x12 shelter for his church. ____ 3. It is NOT about the plan. Thedocument details how old Scouts should be to use certain hand tools and power tools at service projects (including Eagle Scout service projects). As a scout master Ive been involved in the Eagle process with several scouts through the years. Like Charles Series, we have also had problems ensuring that the Life Scout is using the correct materials and doing proper planning BEFORE it is too late. A Scout can begin planning his project as soon as he becomes a Life Scout. Remember, socializing during your workday will help to make things fun, and lead to a more successful project! So, whats important enough to update your volunteers on? Choose an Eagle Scout project in consultation with your unit leader and the benefiting organization. Maybe we should do more than just sign it.we might actually need to TALK to the youth and using EDGE methods learned in Scouting, help him through the process after the proposal is accepted For example, we should KNOW that he is going to use CCA lumberand tell him to rethink it!!! If youre wondering how best to relay information to your volunteers, Id recommend using Google Forms or Facebook Groups to first collect RSVPs, and then group emails to keep in contact. In it, well be covering each of the points below, in detail: Thanks for making our country a better place through your service in Scouting. Steps for the Scout. If this happens, and your project isnt completely finished, you should lead by example and work as hard as possible alongside your remaining volunteers! EAGLE SCOUT LEADERSHIP SERVICE PROJECT CHECKLIST . 14-18 yr old boys just dont have the experience to recognize all the problems they are likely to encounter. This document outlines several minimum guiding protocols that adult leaders and other volunteers must consider for Scouting service projects that include the use of tools. After hearing even just the decision to change the requirements makes me reconsider if it is worth the time and effort for have my boy earn this award and even keep them in scouting. This article is based on the experiences and research of Eagle Scouts, Kevin A, and Cole. Do I have to go back and redo my entire service project workbook? I guess there is way too much money passing hands to do otherwise. This is a space for friendly local discussions. I am an Eagle Scout and have been involved with boys getting their Eagle award in three different districts in three different councils. 24 foot walking bridge and 100 X 4 gravel path complete; and the workbook has built in spell checkreally nice. The Scout Law: (A Scout is.) DOES THE PROJECT HAVE TO HAVE LASTING VALUE? In all likelihood though, youll complete the majority of your Eagle service project plans without any problems, as planned. 1 of the Sweet Sixteen of BSA Safety is Qualified Supervision.. Sometimes an adult in your unit has been designated to provide support for Eagle Scout projects. Why didnt the BSA just surrender, go Microsoft Word, and let us use the features? Now it is so watered down it is no longer the most difficult requirement to becoming Eagle. We needed a national standard, as this is a national award. Had to wonder how you can lead a project when you dont have a plan that will work and a clue how to fix it. Besides the Eagle Scout Project Workbook (No. These people are contributing their time because they want to see your project succeed, so you should do your best to make things as easy as possible for them. Organize whatever supplies, materials, and tools you used for that day and pick up any loose items that may have been left around. After trying to charge the drills and realizing that there wasnt enough time, I asked my volunteers if any of them had access to another power drill. That said, many Scouts find it helpful to focus on merit badges first and the Eagle project second (or vice versa). Its National Forest Week! PS. EAGLE Rank Requirements These rank requirements are official as of Jan. 1, 2021. The fillable version will not open on mobile devices, and web browser PDF helper apps will not support the fillable fields. No. I feel that this scout did not display integrity or citizenship in this project. If there are any important changes that come up while planning your Eagle Project, its crucial that you inform the relevant volunteers, ASAP. If you choose to not follow the new rules for Eagle projects, you should respectfully resign from your position. Running an Eagle Scout service project is the final obstacle that separates most scouts from the 5% who rise up to earn their Eagle rank. Ie. We (troop adult leaders) reviewed the idea and approved proceeding to the planning phase, but expressed concern about the complexity. This is also teaching the scout how to work within parameters that a job application and or format is restrictive. No longer does the project have to have a lasting effect on the community or organization that was helped. Most Eagle BOR members I have sat with do not truly know the requirements of the Eagle Project Workbook at any kind of a detail level. The shelter got built and is an outstanding project. If a Scout has started work toward a rank before that date using requirements that were current before Jan. 1, 2021, except as noted below, the Scout may complete that rank using the old requirements. Now he has had to re-type several pages of the Plan. DOES THE EAGLE PROJECT HAVE TO BE THE LAST REQUIREMENT FINISHED? At the bare minimum, Id recommend providing them with lunch. Paint colorful squares for a game of hopscotch on a school playground. The new process has gutted our successful District Eagle Program, which had never failed to approve a serious Eagle project plan in the ten years I have doing District Reviews. Leadership Tip: As your volunteers begin to arrive, strike up a conversation with whoevers there! 20 Creative Eagle Scout Project Ideas - BillionGraves Blog After everyone has been debriefed, as project leader its your job to now visit each group and ensure that each task is being done correctly. PDF 10 Things to Know About Eagle Scouts - BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA If I had a junior leader who tried to hand write an OPORD from memory I would fire him for being too dumb to use modern tools. Scout gets a signature on proposal and jumps right to project. 33088), which is available at Scout Shops and online at scouting.org/filestore/pdf/33088.pdf. No longer does the Eagle Candidate have to give back to the community that helped that scout earn his advancement. While a Life Scout, participate in a Scoutmaster conference. Why would a scoutmaster waste his time if every life scout automatically makes Eagle. He keeps his promises. Hey, you with the posthole digger! I see the new book as an effort to make sure that the boy scout is not subjected to extra requirements by those who really have no authority expand the scope of what the BSA has intended for the project. We have already dedicated an entire Roundtable to dissecting the document line by line. While I can't tell my past self what I know now, I can teach you all the smart Scouting knowledge that I wish I'd known when just starting out. No. You must use the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook, BSA publication No. The workbook is a pdf which is does not allow for inserting pictures, adding additional space to boxes where required or adding additional lines in the many tables. No council, district, unit, or individual has the authority to add or change requirements or to require additional forms. Eagle Men: A Scoutmaster could work on and earn the Eagle Award up to 1965, when rules were changed instituting a maximum age of 18 for earning Eagleunless the Scout is identified as having special needs. When he was done he presented his detailed plan to the Eagle Scout advisor. For the BORs I have sat on so far this year, many of the members have not been trained in the new process of 2012, to evaluate the Project Plan in its final form and determine Did that Scout fulfill the Eagle Scout Project Requirements as it specifically relates to the planning process of an Eagle Scout project. . Saving lives is a great goal. To show an example of how to navigate an obstacle, Im gonna tell you about a challenge that I had to overcome when leading my Eagle Scout project: During my Eagle project, to construct the care home signs, holes needed to be drilled into our PVC pipes with a power drill. My son just finished his project. If not, can the task be done by you alone so that your tired volunteers can head home? To remind you of what it means to give leadership to others, lets review some of the qualities of a good leader in the context of your Eagle project: While there are many other important leadership qualities outside of what I mentioned here, I believe that these 5 tips are the most important for making your Eagle project a success. By choosing reliable sub-leads and briefing them thoroughly, youll be able to successfully delegate out your leadership responsibilities! Navigating the Eagle Project for Beneficiaries - Scoutmastercg.com By Mark Ray How about during? Yes there is supposed to be a Coach or Mentor but in reality for the projects I review there has been an apparent lack of coaching/mentoring in almost every case so again there is a lack of learning experience which is just as valuable (if not maybe more so in my opinion) as showing leadership or giving to the community, and that is not to take away from the importance of those items. This proposal represents the beginning of planning, and it must be detailed enough to show reviewers that the project meets the requirement, that its feasible, that safety issues will be addressed, and that the Scout has considered his next steps and seems on the right track for a positive project experience. The Eagle Project Idea Generator offers a decision-tree approach for giving you a few project ideas on which you can develop your own project. There was no time to waste, so to adapt to the new challenge I needed to get resourceful. However, the effect of this is a very bitty workbook which scouts are struggling to complete, especially if they have any difficulties such as dyslexia, ADHD, etc. With so many tasks, youll actually be more effective by not getting caught up in the hard work! It is disturbing to see the dumbing down of the requirements and a slap in the face to those who have climbed the trail to the top of Eagle Mountain. It was embarrassing and difficult to tell parents in our community that it was an eagle scout project. Improvise, adapt overcome (yes, this is a meme, but its also a marine corps saying, lol). This could be anything from setting up workstations, to prepping materials, to making sure your tools are all functioning. No more planning. We then spent many hours looking together for a new project and planning his new proposal. Can a Candidate tell them they are doing it wrong? For example, if you know one of your sub-leads has some experience in power tools, you could ask them to take charge of the drilling portion of your project. Then I offer them unsolicited advice, if they would like to stay and receive it on their next step, the plan. 12 (This requirement may be met after age 18 in accordance with Guide to Advancement, topic 8.0.3.1.) An Eagle Project is NOT about teaching boys how life in badly run organizations is. Official BSA Rules For Eagle Project Fundraising (Simplified) In the list below I'll be covering the 11 most important points to keep in mind when fundraising for your Eagle project. I hope you dont disappoint my boys. This is an exercise in leadership, planning and thinking! This means sending over some emails with clear explanations to any questions that might arise around your project. Troop 26, Fort Drum, NY. Congrats, leader! Quit crying about it and making it more difficult than what it really is. This is where i have a problem with the projects. The new workbbok is like filling in job application. Do these guidelines match what your unit already does? No problem! I completed Requirement 5; my Eagle Scout Leadership Service Project and accompanying Workbook in 2010, long before the new rules and guidelines came out. Try to push back, and you have no ground to stand on. I. MAIL: 1325 W. Walnut Hill Lane, Irving, TX 75015-2401. Were you able to finish everything that was planned? So, in summary: Understand the goal of standards and such, but the BSA is setting themselves and their Scouts and Scouters up for accidents and eventual legal action. There are a few issues/challenges we are facing 1. Maybe the national people need to re-look at what the scope of the planning should be. PDF SAFE Project Tool Use - Boy Scouts of America Congratulations on raising and mentoring an Eagle. Towards the end of your workday, you should review everything that your volunteers have done, and consider whether theres anything else that needs to be accomplished. Key elements of the process are explained : The Eagle Scout Rank and the Service Project; Typical Projects MUST THE SCOUT LEAD A CERTAIN NUMBER OF PEOPLE? The BSA Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook is your guide to everything you need to complete the last step on the road to becoming an Eagle Scout! Have a great day! Remember, your volunteers should be notified about things sooner rather than later! Eagle Project Idea Generator - The National Eagle Scout Association How can you expect anyone to pay attention to what you have to say when you cant complete a sentence or know when to end one? Listing materials and costs is more than he has to do at the first stage, but it makes it clear which of those approaches hes talking about. However, I am coming round to the new workbook, but there is a fundamental problem with it. These young men are not licensed construction engineers. Michael Freeman, an Eagle Scout, is an associate editor of Scout Life andScouting magazines. (To learn more about the Eagle Scout service project, see the Guide to Advancement, topics 9.0.2.0 through 9.0.2.16.) The Eagle Project is supposed to be conceived*, planned, and executed by the Eagle candidate - not by the candidate's parents or Scout leaders, or by any representative from the benefiting organization, or any other adult. It has a lot of good Eagle project information. Ok, so Im a mom of 2 current Cub Scouts and one that will start scouting in 2013. WOW can yaall be a little more negative? WHAT SUPPLIES HE NEEDS AND HOW TO GET THEM DONATED. I am sorry your son took it lightly but there are many scouts out there that will embrace the project as the final step in the journey that taught them lessons that will carry each man through his life. PDF is Not appropriate for eagle forms. Trustworthy, Loyal, Obedient. This book does not lower the standards but helps the scout to better understand what needs to be accomplished and how. A better path would have been a role based web application with a responsive design that the Scouts and leaders could access from any device that can mount a modern web browser. I wanted to allow my son to plan his project by himself. To do my duty to God and my country and to obey the Scout Law; To help other people at all times; To keep myself physically strong, mentally awake, and morally straight. But I would like to emphasize that if the coach allows a project to go forward without a thorough review then shame on him/her. Further planning as necessary for success continues to be important, but is evaluated as part of the project at the Scouts board of review. The fact that Eagle advancement has risen from 2% to 4% in no way indicates that the Eagle Scout is truely prepared or worthy.
Orthopedic Nurse Certification Requirements, Stop-dwi Tournament Of Champions 2023, Is Ever Increasing Faith Still On Tv, Pros And Cons Of Citizens Insurance, Articles E